Home > Reviews > Clothes & Gear Reviews

First Look: Lems Shoes Trail Thrasher is a Barefoot MTB Shoe that Wears Well On & Off the Trail

Lems New Trail Thrasher MTB Shoe hero
15 Comments
Support us! Bikerumor may earn a small commission from affiliate links in this article. Learn More

The popular barefoot shoe brand, Lems Shoes, just launched a new MTB/trail shoe called the Trail Thrasher. At its core, the Trail Thrasher is a mountain bike shoe. It takes serious design cues from downhill biking culture, which I think is obvious by its aesthetics.

Lems New Trail Thrasher MTB Shoe first pic

Lems sent me an 11.5 in the Asteroid color way, and it’s a handsome shoe. I’ve been wearing the Trail Thrasher every day for a few weeks now, and it’s proven to be a comfortable trail shoe. I’ve only ridden with the shoe a few times, but I will report back with a full review when I get a good amount of bike time on it.

Lems New Trail Thrasher MTB Shoe side by side

I have reached out to see if there are any plans to offer the Trail Thrasher as a clipless (or Clip in?) shoe that would have a slightly stiffer insole and SPD compatibility. As of this writing, I haven’t heard back. I sure hope so.

OK, let’s get into the meat of it.

A Quick Word on the Name

Lems is a shoe company that I have been wearing since 2017. It’s a great barefoot shoe brand with amazing products and great customer service. On the Lems site and in its marketing, Lems consistently promotes “going outside” and enjoying the natural world, but the term “Trail Thrasher” does not really fit the “leave no trace” ethos that the majority of outdoor enthusiasts practice.

Ok, I’ll get off my soapbox and get on with it.

Lems Trail Thrasher

As you’d expect from a barefoot shoe, the new Trail Thrasher features a wide toe box. This gives your toes room to spread naturally and uses a zero-drop platform that keeps your heel and forefoot at the same level – mimicking how your feet would sit without shoes.

Lems New Trail Thrasher MTB Shoe in the house

Built for both trails and city streets, the Trail Thrasher uses the same beefy outsole as Lems’ Boulder Summit boot. It sports 4mm lugs and zig-zag siping for traction on various surfaces.

Lems New Trail Thrasher MTB Shoe next to current MTB shoes
My current Canyon Solestar MTB shoes for comparison. I like the Canyons because they have a semi-wide toe box

The upper combines nubuck leather with perforated suede in flex zones, allowing your foot to move comfortably while still maintaining durability. My review pair weighs in at 14.2oz (404g) for size 11.5. The low weight is designed to keep your feet comfortable during longer activities without feeling too heavy.

The shoe was designed to work well for mountain biking, commuting, hiking, or daily wear around town. You can remove the minimal insole if you want more ground contact or need extra room inside the shoe for some warm wool socks. It comes with a 16mm stack height and an EVA midsole for cushioning. It’s very comfy.

Trail Thrasher Retail & Detail

Retail: $155

Sizes: 4.5 – 15 (in 1/2 size increments)

Colors: Moss, Ghost, and Astroid (tested)

Lems New Trail Thrasher MTB Shoe colors
  • Waterproofing: None
  • Fit: Lems WIDEST Natural-Shape
  • Upper: Nubuck and Perforated Suede
  • Lining: Polyester
  • Midsole: EVA
  • Outsole: Rugged rubber outsole with 4mm lugs
  • Insole: Minimal Poly Insole
  • Stack Height: 16mm
  • Drop: Zero-Drop
  • Weight: 13.4oz (Men’s 10) 
  • Vegan: No

How They Feel

The thing about Lems Shoes is that they feel excellent as soon as your foot slips inside. I have many models of their shoes, and they all feel consistently good right outta the box.

Lems New Trail Thrasher MTB Shoe with socks
With my Campandgoslow wool socks.

The Trail Thrasher is no different. It felt great, right from the gate. Like all of Lems’ shoes, the Trail Thrasher fits into the brand’s approach of creating foot-shaped footwear that lets your feet function more naturally.

Lems New Trail Thrasher MTB Shoe at my desk

I’ve been in and out of town since getting my review pair, so I haven’t actually done a true mountain bike ride with them yet. But I have worn them every day since receiving them. That includes a 6-day off-the-grid camping trip through the Eastern Sierra Back Country, and so far, they have been great.

As far as any riding in them, well, I’ve ridden the Rivendell to the Post Office a few times with them, and the traction the 4mm lugs offered was great on the Clem’s pedals (MKS Grip Monarch). I’m really looking forward to getting some MTB riding in with these shoes in the very near future.

In Conclusion, But Not Done Yet

So far, it’s hard not to like the Trail Thrasher. It’s a shoe that is both comfortable and versatile. It still feels like a typical Lems Shoe in that it’s sturdy, comfy, well-made, and built to last a very long time. Plus, the aesthetics are very handsome.

A strong believer in the barefoot shoe philosophy, I feel a big difference when my feet aren’t in barefoot shoes. So far these shoes have met my expectations and, as a long-time Lems customer, I have zero reason to think they won’t continue to do so.

Stay tuned here for the full review in the next month or so.

The Trail Thrasher is available for pre-order from November 13-27, with shipping expected in mid-December. The shoe runs true to size and comes in Lems’ widest natural-shape fit. Check ’em out, you won’t be sorry.

LemsShoes.com

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

15 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Matt
Matt
8 days ago

Seems weird to endorse an MTB shoe that you haven’t had a single MTB ride with yet.

Lukasz
Lukasz
8 days ago

…they all feel consistently good tight outta the box…

David
David
7 days ago

How do the size? Are you normally an 11.5? My shoes vary between 11 and 11.5 so not sure what to go with (UK buyer so don’t want to consider returning!)

Dustin S.
Dustin S.
7 days ago

Thanks for exploring this concept! I ride MTB in Altra Lone Peaks because my feet go numb in non-wide toe box shoes! I’m ordering a pair as a X-Mas present to myself!

Karsten Will - Eichkatz.bike

When you wrote about the weight you wrote „My review pair …“ but I think you weighed just one shoe, correct?
Otherwise these would be some seriously light shoes, lighter than the 520 g (for two) sneakers I use.

Maciej
Maciej
7 days ago

I love Lem shoes, would like a flat pedal shoe that fits truer to my feet than Freerider Pros.

But…..how do they hook up on a set of Deftraps (or similar grippy concave pedals)? I’ve stuck with 5.10s for a long time because my feet don’t come off.

And….how do they hold up? Freerider Pros do a pretty good job withstanding being on pins.

I hope these pass muster, but at this point I have more questions than answers (and Lems website touts DH style, but no ad copy about actually working on the bike).

Looking forward to a follow up.

Brian Crosier
7 days ago

Thanks for this article. As a foot and ankle Physical Therapist and a mountain biker, bike packer, backpacker and traveler, I’ve been excited about these nit just as a bike to but as a travel shoe for around town, hiking and backpacking. I got my pair and have been really happy with them for both hiking and biking. An fyi, these do not classify as a barefoot shoe. They are zero drop and foot shaped, but have cushion and structure/stiffness (which doesn’t qualify them as a varefiit style shoe).

Last edited 7 days ago by Brian Crosier
whitepeople
whitepeople
6 days ago

Ron I’d argue that Thrashing and Trashing aren’t the same thing.

syborg
syborg
6 days ago

I use barefoot shoes from Xero, the Prio model, for all my cycling. They’re as comfortable as wearing slippers. I buy the Prio’s for about half of what Lem wants for their shoes.

PoorInRichfield
PoorInRichfield
5 days ago

Look at how lovely that wide toe box is! Very few of Lems’ shoes are actually minimalist shoes (i.e., minimal sole, highly flexible) and these shoes definitely aren’t minimalist. However, these Lems shoes do offer a foot-shaped fit, which is severely lacking in the cycling industry for those of us with wide feet. I dream of the day when road cycling shoes actually have wide toe boxes like these shoes do.

Maciej
Maciej
3 days ago

Pearl Izumi PRO Air road shoes fit my wide(ish) feet great. Had to get decent insoles, but if you want a real high performance road shoe in a 100+ mm last, they’ll do the trick.

Otherwise Lake wides might work (I find them clunky) or you should get Bonts to fit.

Subscribe Now

Sign up to receive BikeRumor content direct to your inbox.